How it works

Slop is about effort,
not tools.

A hand-made asset flip is still slop. A carefully made game that used AI for translation isn’t. We’ll score the work, and we treat AI use as information, not a penalty. Curator reviews haven’t started yet; this page explains how they’ll work.

The score

Four areas, scored 1 to 10

Curators who have played the game will score each area. The nonslop score will be the average.

01

Craft

Consistent art direction, polish, few bugs, and UI and audio that feel finished.

02

Originality

A fresh idea or a real twist, not a fast copy of whatever is trending. Backed by concept timelines.

03

Honesty

Does the AI disclosure match reality? Disclosed AI is fine. Hiding it is the only AI-related penalty.

04

Care

Active updates, a developer who responds, and store screenshots that match the game.

Where AI fits in

Shown, never scored against you.

Every game page quotes the developer’s AI disclosure word for word, with a link to the source and the date we checked it. Players who want fully handmade games will be able to look for the Handcrafted badge.

What we track

  • Art & textures
  • Code
  • Writing & dialogue
  • Voice
  • Music & audio
  • Translation
  • Store & marketing
  • Generated during play
AI disclosed

The developer filed an AI disclosure.

No AI disclosed

No disclosure on the store page. Not proof that no AI was used.

Handcrafted

The developer confirmed to us that no generative AI was used.

Weeding out slop

What slop looks like

Most of these signals can be detected automatically. Curators will make the final call, and every flag will come with its evidence.

Publisher volume

A studio releasing 30+ games a year. Something Steam’s own data can show.

Copying trends

Shows up weeks after a hit indie concept, with no development history.

Store page mismatch

Capsule art and screenshots that look nothing like the actual gameplay.

Asset flips

Store-bought assets used unchanged, stitched into a thin game.

Abandonment

No updates since launch. Bug reports go unanswered.

Unedited AI artifacts

Inconsistent characters, garbled text in images, generic AI store copy.

Badges

What the badges mean

Nonslop Certified

Will go to games scoring 8 or higher in all four areas, awarded by the curator panel.

Original Concept

The earliest known public version of its concept, backed by a dated timeline.

Handcrafted

The developer confirmed no generative AI was used. For players who care.

Flagged

Given when curators find strong slop signals. Evidence and the developer’s reply will always be shown.

Keeping it fair

Credible by design

Reviews from real players

Players will link a Steam account, and votes will only count after real playtime, so brigading and fake reviews won’t work.

Curators plus community

A small curator panel will award badges, and community votes will feed the scores.

Right of reply

Developers will be able to respond to flags and dispute anything we publish. We’ll fix mistakes fast.

Original Concept

For developers

Developer accounts are opening soon. Here’s what they’ll let you do.

Claim your page

Verify you made the game, then confirm or correct its AI disclosure.

Log your concept

Add concept art, devlogs and builds as you go. Each entry is timestamped.

Respond to a flag

Every flag shows your reply right next to the evidence.

Browse the games we track